New York Yankees
League: Major League Baseball
Founded: 1901
Stadium: Yankee Stadium
Location: Bronx
Partners/ Sponsors: Bally Bet, DraftKings and FanDuel
It feels like the same bet that every year there will be a lot of money wagered on the New York Yankees. They are the definition of success in baseball, with 27 World Series championships, although they have not appeared in the Fall Classic since winning it all in 2009. A perennial playoff team, the Yankees do not rebuild, they simply reload, so they are always a great bet to make the postseason, and they are almost always among the preseason favorites to win the World Series. Their recent partnership with DraftKings for an in-stadium lounge has the potential to become one of the first active sportsbook locations in a professional arena/stadium in New York. At the moment, however, the VIP DraftKings Sportsbook Lounge at Yankee Stadium has no kiosks or retail betting capabilities.
New York Giants
League: National Football League
Founded: 1925
Stadium: MetLife Stadium
Location: East Rutherford, NJ
Partners/ Sponsors: DraftKings
Ever since the New York Giants last won the Super Bowl in 2012, they’ve been on the decline. There is a lot of optimism around new coach Brian Daboll and the team, but it will take a year or two before the Giants are again the betting favorites in a difficult NFC East. There is no doubt that the Giants will return to their proud tradition soon enough, though, and will once again command respect from the betting public every Sunday. In the meantime, they’re simply a longshot pick for any Super Bowl or playoff odds.
New York Rangers
League: National Hockey League
Founded: 1926
Stadium: Madison Square Garden
Location: Manhattan
Partners/ Sponsors: BetMGM, Caesars and DraftKings
The New York Rangers might be in the midst of a resurgence behind yet another strong European goaltender. At the very least, they are now a trendy pick to win the Stanley Cup over the next few seasons. They had a disappointing end to their 22-23 season but should be in contention for the near future. We’ll see what the offseason holds for this Original Six team, but expect their future odds for next season to draw plenty of bets.
New York Knicks
League: National Basketball Association
Founded: 1946
Stadium: Madison Square Garden
Location: Manhattan
Partners/ Sponsors: BetMGM, Caesars and DraftKings
There is no professional sports team that keeps its fans in so much optimism and disgust at the same time as the New York Knicks. The heyday of the NBA’s premier New York franchise is long gone, and now fans are stuck with small glimpses of hope followed by the cruel punishment of crushed expectations. The Knicks have made the playoffs just once in the last nine seasons and have won just one playoff series since 99-00 when they advanced to the Eastern Conference Finals. If there is an unlucky team in professional sports, it is the Knicks, and that is never a great team to bet on at the sportsbooks.
New York Jets
League: National Football League
Founded: 1959
Stadium: MetLife Stadium
Location: East Rutherford, NJ
Partners/ Sponsors: BetMGM and WynnBet
No team in the NFL has been as constantly mediocre over the last decade as the New York Jets. They have not made the playoffs since losing in consecutive AFC Championship Games in 2009 and 2010, and they have won at least six games just once in the last six seasons. There has been a revolving door at quarterback, many of which were high draft picks ruined by bad coaching and bad talent around them. It felt like the Jets never wanted to properly rebuild, but that had started to change over the last two seasons. They added veteran quarterback Aaron Rodgers for the 2023-24 season, but he suffered a season-ending injury just four snaps into their first game. Time will tell if he will be able to heal and lead the Jets next season.
New York Mets
League: Major League Baseball
Founded: 1962
Stadium: Citi Field
Location: Queens
Partners/ Sponsors: Caesars
New owners have infused new cash and increased expectations for the New York Mets, even if they have yet to be met. The Mets will also play second fiddle in the city to the Yankees, but there is arguably more to be excited about in Queens than in the Bronx. New York’s other baseball team has some dominant pitchers and exciting hitters, making them a threat for a deep postseason run over the next few years. It remains to be seen how else the Mets can surpass the Braves and Dodgers in the National League, but they are certainly giving it their best efforts to compete at the upper echelons of baseball.
Brooklyn Nets
League: National Basketball Association
Founded: 1967
Stadium: Barclays Center
Location: Brooklyn
Partners/ Sponsors: None
The Nets went all in a few seasons ago when they signed three of the best players in the league: Kevin Durant, Kyrie Irving, and James Harden. They took a risk on pairing three stars that have had issues with their former teams, and it backfired spectacularly. They had a couple of decent playoff runs but failed to reach the NBA Finals. All three stars forced their way out of Brooklyn, leading the Nets to go from a contender to a lottery team in a matter of months. The Nets did get some pieces back in sending them away, but not nearly enough to keep them competitive. The Nets are still relatively new to New York and play second-fiddle to the Knicks, but they still draw plenty of action at New York online sportsbooks.
New York Islanders
League: National Hockey League
Founded: 1972
Stadium: UBS Arena
Location: Elmont
Partners/ Sponsors: None
The move to UBS Arena on Long Island puts the New York Islanders in the center of potentially the next sports betting hub in New York. There are plans and hopes for a casino and sportsbook in Elmont near Belmont Park and UBS Arena, so fans might soon be able to go bet on the Islanders before going to see them in person. The Islanders had two exceptional seasons under Barry Trotz, but the 2021-22 debacle led to Trotz being let go and uncertainty surrounding the team. That faded away this season as they returned to the playoffs. They didn’t last long, but fans now have much more hope for their future.
New Jersey Devils
League: National Hockey League
Founded: 1974
Stadium: Prudential Center
Location: Newark, NJ
Partners/ Sponsors: Caesars and FanDuel
The New Jersey Devils arrived in New Jersey in 1982 after leaving Colorado, and they’ve really been mostly irrelevant without Martin Brodeur in goal. From 1987-2012, the Devils missed the playoffs just three times, equaling the number of Stanley Cups the franchise won in that same span. The Devils played for the Cup on two other occasions, and most of that run came with Brodeur in the crease for New Jersey. Since playing in the Stanley Cup Final in 2012, the Devils have made the playoffs just once, a first-round exit in 2017-18. However, they made the playoffs in the 22-23 season and were able to win their first-round matchup against the rival Rangers. With a loaded roster, you can expect the Devils to push for another Stanley Cup title over the next few seasons.
Buffalo Sabres
League: National Hockey League
Founded: 1970
Stadium: KeyBank Center
Location: Buffalo
Partners/ Sponsors: FanDuel
The Buffalo Sabres own the longest active postseason drought in the NHL at 12 seasons since their last trip to the postseason. Buffalo has finished in last place in its division six times in those 12 playoff-less seasons and has not really been close to playoff contention since being bounced in the first round of the 2011 postseason. Buffalo had a rich history of success with Dominik Hasek and Ryan Miller as goalies in the 1990’s through the 2011 season, building on the franchise's mild success in the 1980’s. However, the lack of scoring and efficient team building has hampered the team’s rebuilding process and kept Buffalo in the cellar for so long. The team came close to a postseason birth last season, finishing just one point shy of a wildcard spot.
Buffalo Bills
League: National Football League
Founded: 1959
Stadium: Highmark Stadium
Location: Orchard Park
Partners/ Sponsors: Caesars and FanDuel
The buzz around the Buffalo Bills has never been this high, not even during their four straight Super Bowl seasons in the early 1990’s. The duo of general manager Brandon Beane and coach Sean McDermott has reinvigorated the declining franchise, and the Bills are going to be Super Bowl favorites for the foreseeable future. The combination of Josh Allen at quarterback with the skill players around him and a defense that has been among the NFL’s best the past four years makes Buffalo a dangerous team to face. After spending 17 long seasons outside the playoffs, Buffalo has been in the postseason five of the last six years and should be there for as long as Allen stays healthy.
New York Red Bulls
League: Major League Soccer
Founded: 1994
Stadium: Red Bull Arena
Location: Harrison, NJ
Partners/ Sponsors: None
The New York Red Bulls were one of the founding members of the MLS, but have never found much success in the league playoffs in more than 20 years on the field. On six occasions, the Red Bulls finished atop the Eastern Conference in the regular season, including three times leading the entire league in points to earn the Supporters Shield. However, in all six of those seasons, the Red Bulls failed to advance to the MLS Cup final. In fact, the one time New York did play for the playoff championship in 2008, it did so after earning the eighth and final playoff spot.
New York Liberty
League: Women’s National Basketball Association
Founded: 1997
Stadium: Barclays Center
Location: Brooklyn
Partners/ Sponsors: FanDuel
One of the original franchises in the WNBA, the New York Liberty is in the midst of a resurgence with superstar Sabrina Ionescu. The team wears a FanDuel patch on their jerseys and more of those jerseys have been flying off the shelf thanks to Ionescu. New York’s WNBA franchise has a proud history of success with four WNBA Finals appearances in the first six years of the league, yet they did not win the title on any of those occasions. They have qualified for the conference finals just four times since that 2002 trip to the WNBA Finals, but were able to get a postseason berth in 2022.
NJ/NY Gotham FC
League: National Women’s Soccer League
Founded: 2006
Stadium: Red Bull Arena
Location: Harrison, NJ
Partners/ Sponsors: None
NJ/NY Gotham FC is an original member of the growing women’s soccer movement in the country that has allowed the NWSL to expand in recent seasons. This was one of the founding franchises of the WPS, the predecessor to the current NWSL, and has kept women’s soccer alive and well in the New York City area for more than a decade. Several members of the U.S. Women’s National Team play their club soccer with Gotham, including defender Imani Dorsey, midfielder Kristie Mewis and forward Margaret Purce.
New York City FC
League: Major League Soccer
Founded: 2013
Stadium: Yankee Stadium
Location: Bronx
Partners/ Sponsors: None
A club in the City Football Group system that also owns Manchester City, New York City FC were the MLS champions in 2021. The Yankees also own 20 percent of the club, which is why it plays its home games at Yankee Stadium and is able to afford to pay its players top dollar. This team has been extremely competitive in MLS since beginning play in 2015, two years after its founding, and they have produced some quality players, including Leeds United’s Jack Harrison and Borussia Dortmund’s Gio Reyna.