Mookie Betts (.377 BA, 6 HR, 25 RBI, 7 SB) currently is the heavy favorite to win the NL MVP thanks to a monster start to the season. He is contributing impressive numbers in multiple categories, which is something only a few of his rivals are even capable of. However, we aren’t buying on the former award winner adding another to his collection in 2024.
One big reason for that are his numbers form the last few seasons. His home run and RBI totals have remained impressive, but his batting average and stolen base totals have been down. He managed to finish with a .307 batting average last season, but only because of a history month he put together late in the season.
The 31-year-old has been a streaky player, which suggests a major course correction will be coming. Last season, Betts posted a .455 batting average with 11 home runs and 30 RBIs in August, but followed it up with a .241 average, one home run, and nine RBIs in September. He put up similar numbers in two other months that year, showing how much his output can fluctuate.
Betts also has a bit of a disadvantage hitting at the top of the LA lineup. While that will lead to impressive run totals, it will limit his ability for RBIs, which are given far more weight with MVP voters.
While we expect Mookie Betts to remain in this race all season, expect to see him fall back down to Earth soon.